Context

A research wave has been conducted regarding the migration of Hermes channel infrastructure, specifically evaluating Zulip and Rocket.Chat. The research was initiated using Codex with Iris as a reference and has produced a suite of recommendation artifacts.

Desired State

A validated, adversarial-reviewed, and synthetically-critiqued migration plan that moves Miadi/Hermes towards a durable Zulip-based session layer while hardening existing security gaps. The orchestration of this review is ready to be launched via the provided Copilot mission.

Action Steps

1. Execute Review: Run .pde/2605142012--d15e067d-a285-43f3-8b66-7e48204222bf/LAUNCH.copilot-orchestration.sh.
2. Audit Platforms: Utilize doublecheck to verify Zulip/Rocket.Chat feature parity claims.
3. Adversarial Critique: Apply the miadi-adversarial-review-kit to challenge the Zulip recommendation.
4. Finalize Backlog: Refine the implementation backlog based on the orchestration output.

Structural Tension

There is a tension between the immediate operational need for a readable mobile review surface (provided by Zulip topics) and the inherent fragility of the current "hand-glued" Miadi production environment. Moving to Zulip resolves this tension but requires a careful "Minimum Live-Integration Bar" to avoid exposing unauthenticated execution paths.

Related

• Miadi Production: /src/Miadi
• Integrated Nexus: /usr/local/src/miadi-integrated-nexus
• Orchestration Kit: jgwill/miadi-orchestration-kit#main

---

Artifact Inventory (Categorized by Type)

📝 Markdown Documentation

• 00-discussionfeed-perplexity-260514.md: Raw research feed.
• hermes-channel-migration-codex-27-prompt.md: The Codex prompt that initiated this wave.
• survey--hermes-channels--260514-2ba9880a-2e5e-4333-85c1-94861e85a9b9-ksess.md: Session summary.

🐚 Shell Scripts

• LAUNCH.sh: Initial launch script.
• .pde/2605142012--d15e067d-a285-43f3-8b66-7e48204222bf/LAUNCH.copilot-orchestration.sh: Orchestrated review launcher.

📑 Research Recommendation Suite (channel-migration-recommendations-260514/)

• 00-executive-recommendation.md
• 01-current-capability-map.md
• 02-platform-fit-matrix.md
• 03-migration-architecture.md
• 04-replace-refactor-keep.md
• 05-security-and-identity-gaps.md
• 06-implementation-backlog.md
• 07-hitl-questions.md

🎯 PDE & Mission Specifications

• .pde/2605142012--d15e067d-a285-43f3-8b66-7e48204222bf/mission.prompt.md: Structured delegation for the orchestration review.

⚙️ Session Data

• survey--hermes-channels--260514-2ba9880a-2e5e-4333-85c1-94861e85a9b9-ksess: Raw session data.